I was really curious how these would turn out. The idea sounded great to me, but several of the commenters on the original recipe made me a little concerned. I'm definitely a risk taker when it comes to trying recipes, though, so on I forged. In a surprise to everyone, I think I followed the cookie recipe exactly as written! It's a pretty basic cookie recipe, but uses the chopped PopTarts as the mix-in.
Because some of the commenters on the original post stated that the cookies were a little bland, I decided to go my own route on the glaze. I made the glaze as listed, but light on the cream. Then, I added a splash of vanilla (this is always a good decision), and strawberry jam (I just added it until I got a flavor and consistency I liked) before drizzling over the top off the cookies. The jam made the color a delightful pink, plus the blast of strawberry flavor brought out the best of the PopTart filling flavor.
These cookies are delicious and FUN! I am excited to try some other varieties like a cookies and cream version or even maple and brown sugar.
Comments